Television

Doctor Who 11.6 Review: Demons of the Punjab

One of the things we love most about Doctor Who is how, for all the science fiction concepts and alien worlds it throws at us, it still has the power to educate as well as entertain. This educational aspect has been an integral part of the show’s DNA since the very beginning, with the First Doctor and friends regularly visiting key moments from history and rubbing shoulders with figures like Marco Polo, King Richard and Maximilien Robespierre with not a monster or alien in sight. Demons of the Punjab may throw a couple of monster in to the mix, but for all intents and purposes, the episode is much more concerned with the period setting as opposed to the monsters and action.

Centering on a piece of history seldom touched in either Doctor Who or other popular media, the story this week takes us to India in 1947, to the very beginning of the Partition, a time of great political upheaval that saw the formation of Pakistan at the cost of millions of lives. Vinay Patel‘s script is chock full of historical facts and fascinating insights, all especially useful for this reviewer, who knew very little of what happened during this period. But where the script really shines is the more personal approach it takes to exploring these events, utilizing its characters to tell an informative and emotionally resonant story that is expertly woven into the setting.

Of all the episodes this season, Demons is easily one of the best in terms of pacing. Whilst by no means a kinetic, rip-roaring story, here the smaller character moments and the quieter, contemplative scenes drive the story on, as opposed to feeling like a sudden pause in the narrative. Patel creates an interesting set of characters here, with the relationship between radicalized Manish (Hamza Jeetooa) and his heroic brother Prem (Shane Zaza) a particular stand-out, whilst the alien Vajarians and the mystery behind their incursion is given plenty of depth and resonance.

It’s a tightly plotted and emotional story, offering a solid mix of science fiction and real-world history, resulting in an emotional final act that finally gives Mandip Gill the time to shine after five episodes with little to do. Her desire to meet her Grandma in her youth and the subsequent dilemma she faces when she learns history didn’t play out as she’d initially believed is beautifully played by Gill, whilst the subsequent exchange between Yasmin and Graham (Bradley Walsh) is lovely stuff indeed.

However, for all the episode’s brilliance, the central denouement of having the Doctor and her companions forced to let terrible events unfold to preserve history is somewhat lessened in power by the fact a similar conceit was used to greater effect just three episode prior in Rosa. The drama is compelling nonetheless, with solid performances from all concerned, tense direction from Jamie Childs and composer Segun Akinola‘s best musical score yet, but there is no escaping the nagging feeling that the episode’s power is somewhat diminished by the fact we’ve seen a similar beat play out much the same way just a few weeks ago.

Despite these reservations though, Demons of the Punjab is still a brilliant and timeless Doctor Who story, the kind which could easily have worked back in 1963 just as effectively as today. Light on monsters and scares, heavy with history and emotional depth, but still just as entertaining and enjoyable as any Who episode, it’s a fantastic insight into a part of history barely seen or discussed, as well as a powerful piece of drama that challenges audiences both young and old.

 

 

 

Doctor Who is back on BBC One next Sunday. Be sure to check out our Series Blog and join us for our verdict of Episode 7. 

6 thoughts on “Doctor Who 11.6 Review: Demons of the Punjab

  1. Yes the episode has the positives you clearly identify, but for us this series is specialising in over the top morality messages where constantly the human race are the only villains.

    Like

    • I know what you’re saying Michael but I think these stories are long overdue and, as Matt says, no-one else is covering them.

      These are stories I haven’t heard before and even after watching had to do more research. Think of the Tom Baker era with him taking on many politically important issues. You can’t underestimate the power of Who, nor it’s place among all kinds of ages.

      I always want a show to challenge me, to be unexpected and it’s certainly doing that with Jodie. Even more so in this era of human’s thinking we’re better than the Earth we reside on and, yeah, that’s not everyone but if this can speak to a younger generation with hope, reflection and conscience then I’m in.

      Liked by 3 people

    • Fair point Michael, but that’s one of the main reasons I like science fiction and Doctor Who – it offers you the opportunity to comment on issues and debates that are taking place in our society through the veil of a fantasy (or in this case, historical) setting. Doctor Who at its best is challenging and relevant, as well as entertaining.

      I think only Rosa and this episode have really been moralistic in terms of their story content though – and I personally think they’ve been the better stories because they offer some real human drama in and among the science fiction.

      Granted, Arachnids in the UK’s monsters were the result of a shady businessman, but then a lot of Jon Pertwee’s stories in the 70’s had the same idea. I think it’s been a good mix of stories this year so far, and there has been a nice balance between human villains and alien villains like Tim Shaw, the Remnants and the P’Ting too.

      Liked by 2 people

  2. Thanks for your comments, but it seemed to me that the doctor was apologising for the decision to create two countries (and the deaths) without a proper perspective of why that was done. I started with the Doctor from the original series when it was hide behind the sofa time and there has been none of that in this series and believe that this team have run out of ideas before they start. i just hope that they prove me wrong as it is a strong cast with little to scare. Whilst the best the episode of the series the P’Ting wasn’t a villain as it didn’t deliberately kill.

    Like

    • I’ll admit there hasn’t been a scary one yet, which is one of my favourite things in Doctor Who. I also think there was enough information there to warrant viewers to go out and research the subject in depth after the episode in regards to why Partition happened. Other historical episodes have done the same. And I think it was totally right for the Doctor to be upset and sorry about a political decision that resulted in two million deaths. Not out of character at all.

      Also remember that when Doctor Who was first created, it was to educate as well as entertain. The behind-the-sofa suff came later on and almost by accident. It’s nice to see some of that returning to the show. Though I’m like you – I’m hoping for a proper scary one soon – lots of new writers still to come and show what they’ve got.

      Hope you enjoy the rest of the series Michael 🙂

      Liked by 2 people

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.