There’s a high likelihood that if you’ve either seen the fascinating trailer for Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim’s You Can See Everything, or already seen a comedic version of moments from that trailer online, you’ll head into the cinema with a pre-empted idea of what to expect or, more to the point, what you might feel about the subject matter and the main focus of this documentary, which is Elizabeth Holmes.

For those who don’t know, context is important, and while the film offers its own initial guidance over who she is and why she’s being sent to prison, 34 days after the film itself ‘begins’, let’s offer you some background. Holmes was the CEO of a blood-testing company called Theranos, one that claimed it could perform a host of vital tests with a very small drop of blood, when in fact it couldn’t – something that was revealed via an investigative report by The Wall Street Journal. Holmes was consequentially charged with fraud, along with her older partner Ramesh ‘Sunny’ Balwani. The story made its way in a book Bad Blood: Secrets and Lies in a Silicon Valley Startup before being turned in a miniseries, The Dropout, starring Amanda Seyfried. In You Can See Everything, we join her just before she’s sent to prison for 11 years, with her new partner – Billy Evans – and their young children, in their San Diego beach house rental.

From this point, if you want to go into the film blind – i.e. without any further information over what’s coming – I’d genuinely say: Stop reading now and come back afterwards. Seriously.

Close-up documentary poster featuring a smiling face and the title “You Can See Everything”.

You Can See Everything is broken into two parts, the world we’re introduced to for Elizabeth, Billy and their children before she goes to jail, and the second half where reenactments and a major actor arrives for an absolutely fascinating twist on what type of film this is. In principle, it’s somewhat of an experimental documentary, playing with themes of how we perceive what we see, and the examination of what we allow others to see – and those things can be exceedingly interlinked.

Co-director, and interviewer, Nathan Fielder spends a lot of the time trying to find the true story beneath the surface of what’s been created, especially as Holmes still believes she’s completely innocent of the charges. He’s endeavouring to break through the barriers, and to understand why she thinks she didn’t do anything wrong. While their conversation is often progressing, or getting deeper, her partner Billy will often step in just as things might be cracked. The first half of the film sees Holmes in various states of human emotion before she’s taken off to prison, which in truth is reasonable. Despite select wider shots, the camera is persistently close into everyone’s faces, so micro expressions are not hidden, if you’re intrigued by that type of thing (I am). Throughout, I’d say you’re invited to make your own decisions on her wellbeing and mental state, to judge her answers and insights, as to whether she’s guilty or innocent, but it’s tricky to get a grasp of her state of mind, in an everyday sense.

Close-up portrait of a serious man with dark hair and stubble

Billy is less difficult to read, even though I think he believes he’s hiding things well from what we see. He’s everything that’s harmful about toxic American money and men like him. While it suggests Evans has some kind of deep love, or a fixation, for Elizabeth and that could well be true, much of his true character spills out aggressively when she’s out of the picture. At one point, in the second half of the film where Amanda Seyfried has joined Nathan to reenact some scenes that Holmes couldn’t film, but have been written down by Fielder, he suggests because he knows “people who can do just about anything,” he’s insinuating he has enough secret power to make people disappear, and it’s likely to be related to funds from his mysterious wealthy parents.

Whether any of this is an illusion or not, we can’t be sure (in the realms of being fair to viewpoints) but if you enjoy ‘reading’ people, then You Can See Everything is an absolute treasure trove. It’s likely that Billy is probably everything you think he is, as you witness his manipulation of people, well, until he meets Nathan who never reacts as he believes he will. He’s control-hungry, thinking he’s giving honest answers but without the usual argument back he’s probably expecting. His hostile rant at the dinner table, in the second half of the film, tell you everything you need to know. And, what’s more interesting is how people are when Billy is there, it’s certain Holmes is wholly reliant on his existence, but when her parents visit, they’re clearly troubled by the situation, and when her dad tries to give his opinion, Billy will often suddenly step to stop conversations.

Two men facing each other in a dimly lit room

And then there’s Elizabeth Holmes herself. It’s hard to conclude if this is a story designed to make you feel sympathy for her, or to decide for yourself, as that’s very much up in the ocean air of the beach house. Whoever she was before this entire situation, we will never truly know beyond her own promotion before the fall out. The big question Fielder wants her to answer is whether she knew that the Theranos device couldn’t do what they said it could, and if Holmes understands that specific words she used would complicate what people believe. There’s a key moment where Nathan shows Billy and Elizabeth a famous Abbott and Costello routine – which has been emulated in comedy circles ever since – called ‘Who’s on First?’ that plays on the names of people in a baseball team. He uses this as a technique to unpick whether Holmes comprehends why the situation is funny to the audience, and while she finds it funny, she doesn’t appear to understand what the actual joke was, which leads to Billy pushing again on how she ‘thinks differently’ to most people, which is also something they attribute to how Nathan is.

With this lingering, there’s a non-spoken conversation as to whether Holmes has some form of neurodiversity, of undiagnosed origins, but this is never determined. For me, she comes across as feeling like she’s trapped inside another body (like Obsession or Get Out), and she’s not whoever she once might have been. But, again as one of the many complications that you’ll go through, how much of her reaction is real, or pre-planned, is pretty much impossible to decide upon. One truth is that everything here is not normal, and I don’t find myself that day-to-day ‘normal’, but there’s being a little different, and there’s this amalgamation of documentary, psychodrama and damn right addictive intrigue.

Close-up of a person wearing glasses and holding a takeaway coffee cup

If there are smoke and mirrors here, it’s certainly a mix of psychological and determined, and it becomes a unique way of portraying the story Fielder chooses to communicate. This isn’t a documentary you’ve seen before and, even since my viewing, I’m still grappling with whether the dramatic reconstruction eschews the entire view, due to the surreal nature of the situation, and if this helps the overall narrative.

It’s also hard to know if the location itself was pre-planning by the A24 production team, in order to facilitate the latter half when Seyfried enters the scene, but it does work. Sure, Holmes and Evans did rent and live there up to her incarceration, but you wonder if Fielder and Oppenheim have hoped an overall plan would be to bring it back here in the end. And, as magic tricks are discussed by Nathan with Elizabeth, are there subtle suggestions signs directing us towards the overall composition of the piece?

Frequently absorbing, remarkable and utterly insane at the same time, and as a character study, this is one of the most compelling in years and as a documentary, it blurs the lines of reality from what we’re observing. You will need to talk about You Can See Everything after you’ve seen it, just to try and focus your own conclusions but, let it be said, those discussions could be as fascinating as what you’ll witness.

Five yellow five-pointed stars on a white background

You Can See Everything is in cinemas now from A24

Please leave a Reply!

Author

Recent Posts

Trending

Proudly powered by WordPress